News

A victim broke down as her abuser received his sentence

FRIDAY 2.45pm: THE victim of repeated childhood sexual assault more than 40 years ago has broken down in relief as her now elderly abuser was sentenced to at least 10 months in jail.

Lismore District Court Judge Clive Jeffrey sentenced Lismore man Winton Leslie Smith, 80, to two years and four months in prison, with a non-parole period of 10 months.

In sentencing Smith, Judge Jeffrey was required to take into account the offender's age and health, as well as the sentencing standards of the era in which the offences were committed.

Smith showed no emotion as corrective service officers entered the court to take him into custody.

NOT FORGOTTEN: Winton Leslie Smith, 80, pictured outside Lismore Court House, pleaded guilty to historic child sex assault crimes on a 13-year-old girl.
NOT FORGOTTEN: Winton Leslie Smith, 80, pictured outside Lismore Court House, pleaded guilty to historic child sex assault crimes on a 13-year-old girl. Hamish Broome

Last November Smith pleaded guilty to four historical sexual assault charges: two counts of indecent assault on a female, and two counts of attempted carnal knowledge.

The offences date back to between 1969 and early 1971 in South Lismore, when the victim was just 13-years-old.
In sentencing Smith, Judge Jeffrey noted he had made full admissions to police and pleaded guilty at the earliest possible opportunity.

He said there was "no suggestion" of any similar conduct since the offences took place 46 years ago.

He noted the Smith had the support of his wife and her eldest daughter throughout the court proceedings.

He described Smith as "physically frail", with medical issues including chronic kidney disease, arthritis, diabetes, lymphatic leukaemia, and various eye diseases.

However Judge Jeffrey he must "recognise the harm done to the victim and the community" in punishing Smith.
The court heard that the victim had been "significantly affected" by the abuse, suffering anxiety and depression, and undergone counselling throughout her life.

It wasn't until April 2015 that she summoned the courage to finally report the matter to police.

Judge Jeffrey also classed one of the offences as "toward the top end" of seriousness.

On that occasion, the offence was "planned" and involved an attempted rape of the victim which was only avoided because she kicked and screamed until he gave up.

The victim wept tears of relief as the jail sentence was handed down and hugged her supporters.

Smith was allowed a brief opportunity to talk to his lawyer before he was taken away.

 

FRIDAY 6am: SHE has waited 46 years for justice but now the victim of child sexual abuse by a Lismore man must wait no longer.

Winton Leslie Smith, 80, will be sentenced today at 1pm in the Lismore District Court after a protracted sentencing procedure which began on Wednesday morning.

Last year the retired bricklayer pleaded guilty to two counts of indecently assaulting a female under 16, and two counts of attempted carnal knowledge of a girl between 10 and 16, which happened between 1969 and early 1971.

His victim wept throughout yesterday's proceedings, which ended anti-climatically when District Court Judge Clive Jeffrey declared he would wait a day before delivering his final sentence.

 

NOT FORGOTTEN: Winton Leslie Smith, 80, pictured outside Lismore Court House, pleaded guilty to historic child sex assault crimes on a 13-year-old girl.
NOT FORGOTTEN: Winton Leslie Smith, 80, pictured outside Lismore Court House, pleaded guilty to historic child sex assault crimes on a 13-year-old girl. Hamish Broome

In sentencing Smith, Judge Jeffrey must take into account the sentencing regime that was in place in 1971, as well as Smith's advanced age.

The court heard Smith was "physically frail" with several chronic medical issues including leukaemia, chronic kidney disease, and glaucoma.

A suspended sentence has not been ruled out.

His legal aid lawyer Hugh van Dugteren said Smith had also made full admissions to police when confronted by the claims, pleaded guilty, and had demonstrated remorse.

He added that the penalties for Smith's crimes were "far more lenient" in the 1970s than the present day.

 

NOT FORGOTTEN: Winton Leslie Smith, 80, pictured outside Lismore Court House, pleaded guilty to historic child sex assault crimes on a 13-year-old girl.
NOT FORGOTTEN: Winton Leslie Smith, 80, pictured outside Lismore Court House, pleaded guilty to historic child sex assault crimes on a 13-year-old girl. Hamish Broome

But Crown Prosecutor Ben Cochrane cautioned Judge Jeffrey to "not lose sight of the serious nature of the offences" in light of Smith's old age and health.

He warned it was "dangerous" to rely on some of the existing precedents because they weren't specific enough about crucial details like the victim's age and the nature of the acts committed by the perpetrator.

He argued Smith medical problems "were not terribly unusual" and appropriate medical care could be provided in jail.

Mr Cochrane also submitted that the historical nature of the crimes should not justify a more lenient sentence.

Smith was in his early 30s when he sexually abused his victim, who was known to him, while she was just 13.

The offences happened on two separate occasions over at least a two year period.

Smith remains on bail, and was supported by his wife and one of his daughters in the courtroom.

As he left, he muttered: "This is only dividing the family even bloody more".

Topics:  child sex abuse editors picks northern rivers crime sex assault


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Ballina a stop for Sydney to Surfers

Ballina to help smash the $300k goal for Youth Off The Streets.

LOUD show of young art talent

YOUTH ART AWARD: Erin Cattle, of Ballina Coast High School, was one of the students awarded  for her work in the LOUD in the Gallery art exhibition.

Artistic talent of local youth on display at Ballina

Chicks with attitude help make mother's day

MADE WITH LOVE: The CWA Ballina branch will be selling delicious baked goods, preserves, bottles treats and handicrafts at their Mothers Day stall on May 5.

CWA annual fundraiser selling funky crafts and baked treats

Local Partners

Simon Baker and Rebecca Rigg pledge big sum to flood appeal

THE Ballina-raised star and his wife confirmed the donation to charity organisation Rise Above the Flood.

Patti Smith: the mother of punk gave Jim Morrison his wings

Patti Smith at Bluesfest 2017 in Byron Bay.

One of the most exhilarating performances in recent Blues history

UPDATED: Patti Smith donates large sum for flood recovery

Patti Smith at Bluesfest 2017 in Byron Bay.

The artist performed two shows at Bluesfest 2017

Bluesfest Day 2: From Jason Momoa to Mary J Blige

Hollywood star Jason Momoa was happy to interacts with fans backstage at Bluesfest 2017.

Chris Hemsworth and Matt Damon gave the festival a Hollywood touch

Logies 2017: Meldrum's odd speech as Samuel Johnson wins Gold

SAMUEL Johnson’s Gold Logie win was swiftly overshadowed when his speech was taken over by Australian media icon Molly Meldrum.

Logies 2017: Who's taken the coveted gongs?

Kerri-Anne Kennerley poses with the Hall Of Fame Logie Award.

Award winners from Australian television industry's night of nights

Logies 2017: Samuel Johnson dedicates award to sister Connie

Samuel Johnson wins Best Actor at 2017 Logies.

'My sister is succumbing to the perils of cancer': Samuel Johnson

Logies 2017: Dave Hughes roasts Channel Seven CEO

Dave Hughes hosts opens the 2017 Logies.

Hughes sends shockwaves through Logies audience

Logies 2017: Stars are dazzling as the night begins

Karl Stefanovic and Lisa Wilkinnson hit the red carpet.

Melbourne's rolled out the red carpet for tonight's Logie Awards

Logies 2017: Karl stays sober to keep his body a temple

After famously being accused of being a little worse for wear at previous Logies, Karl Stefanovic reckons he is staying sober because his "body is a temple".

He's laying off the booze because his body is a temple, he said.

Logies 2017: She's in white but they aren't in jackets

She's still claiming ownership of white, apparently.

What dodgy real estate ads really mean

This dilapidated house was described as an ‘Edwardian timber home, open to your imagination’. That’s a nice way of putting it.

Real estate writing is just outsourced lying, says one writer

SOLD: Iconic M'boro pub set to be transformed

Shane Muller from Maryborough Motorcycles will be opening up a showroom and café at the Shamrock Hotel.

The Shamrock Hotel is set to be transformed in the next two months.

Coast developer looks to prime real estate's future

MANY OPTIONS: Sunshine Coast developer Graeme Juniper is considering what to do with a prime piece of real estate he owns on Radical Bay on Magnetic Island, near Townsville.

Radical Bay is World Environment Heritage-listed.

This small box of a unit just sold for $1 million

Elizabeth Bay unit has charming views to Sydney Heads.

If this doesn't scream 'housing bubble', nothing does.

MILLIONAIRES ROW: Is this Toowoomba's biggest house?

STUNNING PROPERTY: The home in lot five at Kara View Court is framed with Table Top Mountain as a backdrop.

When entering Kara View Crt, it's hard to ignore the stunning home

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!