Sport

Time to get tough

Manly’s Steve Matai is put on report for a high tackle during the Sea Eagles’ NRL qualifying final against Canterbury last Friday. Despite a long history of similar offences, Matai was suspended for only one week.
Manly’s Steve Matai is put on report for a high tackle during the Sea Eagles’ NRL qualifying final against Canterbury last Friday. Despite a long history of similar offences, Matai was suspended for only one week. GETTY IMAGES

DISCIPLINE is vital to success in sport - just ask any decent coach.

It's also vital to the success of a sport, so it might be time the National Rugby League mentioned that to those who run the judiciary and those who decide how games are refereed.

Manly centre Steve Matai has been suspended for one week for a high tackle against Canterbury in the first round of the play-offs.

One week!

The bloke has a record as long as your arm.

If it was a repeat drink-driving offender he would not just have lost his licence for years but probably be in jail.

In what has been a great season of rugby league, high tackles and shoulder charges have been a blight on the game.

It's time to get tough on high tackles like a decade ago and, as they have done in rugby union, it's time to outlaw shoulder charges, which are fine if they connect with the body but sickening when they connect with the head.

There's too little margin for error - just ask the Dragons' Dean Young.

Players aren't stupid. Matai and his like know that the judiciary has long stopped taking firm action so they are prepared to risk it.

Bring back decent suspensions and the high shots will stop.

So much for the judiciary; what about the referees?

In a sport where rules have been changed to allow tries that didn't use to be tries, one way of seeing more attacking play would be to keep the defence back a genuine 10 metres.

Manly coach Geoff Toovey alluded to the poor 10 metres in the Sea Eagles' loss to the Bulldogs - and he's right.

Watch a game from the 1990s on TV.

See how much more open it is with the teams being kept further apart.

The attacking team has more time to use the ball and it's simply more entertaining.

Players on the field know how far they can stretch the rules.

If they can defend from an off-side position they will do it all game - why wouldn't you?

It's an effective tactic but not much fun for the spectators.

They won't do it if they know it's going to bring a penalty.

A more open game may also result in more line breaks and if it did the referees would need to be on top of that, too.

Players now know they are unlikely to be sin-binned even if they lie all over a tackled player to prevent a quick play-the ball and a try-scoring opportunity.

They don't mind conceding a penalty if it means avoiding a try, but they might think twice if the sin bin was used as liberally as it used to be.

It's all about discipline.

The NRL has come a long way in the past decade but a tougher judiciary, providing a genuine 10 metres and bringing the sin bin back into vogue would make a good game even better.

Topics:  manly sea eagles, nrl, steve matai


Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Hurry! Reserved seating selling fast for Pro Bull Riding

Luke Nichols riding Rap Dancer at the PBR Bullriding Rural Weekly Live Series held at the Grafton Showgrounds. Photo:Bruce Thomas / Daily Examiner March 28, 2015

Numbered seats still available for PBR Live Series finale

Take your tastebuds on a gourmet tour of Northern Rivers

Rebecca Zentveld, (right) from Zentveld’s Coffee, with (from left) Rebekka Battista from Our House, and Ballina-on-Richmond Rotarians Wendy Marsh and Col Lee, promoting the gourmet tour which is part of this year’s Ballina Fine Wine and Food Festival.

Flavours of the Northern Rivers Gourmet Tour in July.

Dig deep for cash to keep the music alive in Ballina

Summerland Credit Union Ballina branch manager Amanda Petersen with the cash prize in the Ballina Coastal Country Music fundraising raffle, with (back, left) raffle co-ordinator Carmel Hayman from the Rotary Club of Ballina and Belinda Cordery from Summerland Credit Union.

Tickets for Ballina Coastal Country Music Festival.

Latest deals and offers

Call for pool plaque to shine in a prominent place

BALLINA RSL sub-branch members are keen to ensure a memorial plaque will be in a prominent position when the Ballina War Memorial Pool is upgraded.

Hurry! Reserved seating selling fast for Pro Bull Riding

Luke Nichols riding Rap Dancer at the PBR Bullriding Rural Weekly Live Series held at the Grafton Showgrounds. Photo:Bruce Thomas / Daily Examiner March 28, 2015

Numbered seats still available for PBR Live Series finale

Take your tastebuds on a gourmet tour of Northern Rivers

Rebecca Zentveld, (right) from Zentveld’s Coffee, with (from left) Rebekka Battista from Our House, and Ballina-on-Richmond Rotarians Wendy Marsh and Col Lee, promoting the gourmet tour which is part of this year’s Ballina Fine Wine and Food Festival.

Flavours of the Northern Rivers Gourmet Tour in July.

Dig deep for cash to keep the music alive in Ballina

Summerland Credit Union Ballina branch manager Amanda Petersen with the cash prize in the Ballina Coastal Country Music fundraising raffle, with (back, left) raffle co-ordinator Carmel Hayman from the Rotary Club of Ballina and Belinda Cordery from Summerland Credit Union.

Tickets for Ballina Coastal Country Music Festival.

Good Guys labels Ballina boy Braydan a Super Kid

National Super Kid finalist Braydan Webb with Good Guys Ballina store manager Dax Cowan.

Braydan Webb a national finalist in the inaugural Super Kid Awards.

WATCH: Bong throwing at Nimbin MardiGrass

GO LARGE: Mark visiting from Brisbane scored a huge 30-plus metre throw at the MardiGrass bong throwing competition.

No shortage of brave (or foolish) competitors in the "Hemp Olympix".

Calling all musos for NCEIA Dolphin awards

ON STAGE: Electronic duo Nocturnal Tapes, Lachie Mulligan on electronics and Harry Suttor on guitar and vocals, at the 2015 Dolphin Awards ceremony.

Entries are open to independent musicians to audition

NYPD join dance challenge

New York Police respond to NZ dance challenge.

New York's finest accept Kiwi dance challenge.

NZ Police Issue Dance Challenge

NZ Police doing the running man dance.

Video of NZ Police doing the running man dance and challenging police forces around...

Dash cam as car rolls dodging rabbit

A car rolls over after dodging a rabbit.

This is why they say don't swerve for wildlife.

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog

VIDEO: Art Deco fan pays $835,000 for Imperial Hotel

No Caption

Iconic "Impy" sold at a bargan price to bidder who loves Art Deco.

RBA warns of future apartment oversupply

Toowoomba: Crest Apartments and Burke & Wills, Ruthven Street ( view from Neil Street) Photo Bev Lacey / The Chronicle

RBA says oversupply of apartments poses risk to household finances