Business

Director involved in $176m collapse wants luxury detention

The Remuera house in which convicted Dominion Finance director Ann Butler wants to serve a home detention sentence.
The Remuera house in which convicted Dominion Finance director Ann Butler wants to serve a home detention sentence.

A DIRECTOR of Dominion Finance, which lost investors more than $176 million, wants to serve home detention in her $6.8 million Remuera mansion.

Company director Ann Butler was one of six directors of Dominion Finance when it went under in 2008.

Butler pleaded guilty yesterday to seven Securities Act charges of making untrue statements in a prospectus and investment statements.

Shortly before proceedings started in the High Court at Auckland, she asked the security guard if she could get her tissues from her handbag.

The 64-year-old answered "guilty" in a steady voice as each of the seven charges was read out by the court registrar.

Justice Robert Dobson convicted Butler and called for a report on her assets. It is understood the Crown will be seeking reparations for investors.

She was remanded on bail for sentencing next month.

Her lawyer, Tim Mullins, asked that a report be prepared on the suitability of Butler's home as a place to serve a home detention sentence.

Butler left court with a supporter and returned to the Remuera home, which she part-owns with fellow Dominion director Robert Whale, according to the property's title.

The house has been on the market for more than a year, a real estate agent said. The advertising bills it as "Paradise on offer here", with four bedrooms, parking for five cars, a wine cellar, a home theatre and a library.

Dominion Finance investor Owen Hoddinott said he hoped Butler's home would be sold and the money shared among investors.

Mr Hoddinott, who lost $100,000 of his retirement savings, said the idea of Butler living in a "plush place" did not sit well with investors.

"Why not somewhere less expensive?"

The 66-year-old school teacher said he'd had to go back to work part-time to make ends meet.

"Really, at the time, it just about killed me," he said. "The nights I spent just worrying about it, it still rankles me today to think that the money just disappeared."

Dominion Finance, which offered commercial and property loans, went under in September 2008 owing 5,937 investors more than $176.9 million.

Its sister company, North South Finance, was placed in receivership in 2010, owing $31 million to 3,900 debenture holders.

Butler's fellow Dominion directors Vance Arkinstall, Richard Bettle, Robert Whale and Paul Forsyth will go on trial next month.

Butler's husband, Terry, was to have joined them, but he died in March of cancer.

Financial Market Authority head of enforcement Belinda Moffat, said Butler was the 27th company director to be convicted in cases brought by the authority.

"She has accepted that she failed to perform her role as a director and did not take the steps required to ensure she was aware of the true position of the companies."

Topics:  editors picks, finance, investment, nz


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Welcome to Northern Rivers’ first golf course of its kind

IT’S OPEN: The Ballina Disc Golf Course at Bicentennial Gardens was officially opened last week by US-born disc golf player Jesse Amos, who pushed for the course, and Ballina Shire councillor Jeff Johnson.

Reports of at least one hole-in-one already

Who wants to be an engineer?

Sparks flly as the laser cutter slices through a 3/4 in sheet of steel at Adnought Sheet metal Fabrications. Photo: Chris Ison / The Morning Bulletin

Calling young people who have thought about an engineering career

'Urgent repairs' needed at Ballina rugby league club

Ballina Seagulls players pictured in September 2015.

Ballina Seagulls fans advised not to sit in grandstand

Latest deals and offers

Bring home the bacon at Northern Rivers festival

LES Wiles isn’t telling porkies when he says this Sunday’s Alstonville Family Festival will be lots of fun.

Welcome to Northern Rivers’ first golf course of its kind

IT’S OPEN: The Ballina Disc Golf Course at Bicentennial Gardens was officially opened last week by US-born disc golf player Jesse Amos, who pushed for the course, and Ballina Shire councillor Jeff Johnson.

Reports of at least one hole-in-one already

Who wants to be an engineer?

Sparks flly as the laser cutter slices through a 3/4 in sheet of steel at Adnought Sheet metal Fabrications. Photo: Chris Ison / The Morning Bulletin

Calling young people who have thought about an engineering career

'Urgent repairs' needed at Ballina rugby league club

Ballina Seagulls players pictured in September 2015.

Ballina Seagulls fans advised not to sit in grandstand

FitzSimons brings Republic mission to Northern Rivers today

The Australian Republican Movement’s National Chair Peter FitzSimons AM.

Peter FitzSimons will be speaking in Lismore and Ballina today

Backpacker tax: Cut it in half or scrap it?

Janelle Saffin and Shadow Minister for Rural Affairs Joel Fitzgibbon discuss the proposed backpacker tax outside Janelle’s office.

Shadow Minister Joel Fitzgibbon: Backpacker tax should be scrapped.

Vanessa from the Northern Rivers, Vivid queen of Sydney

LOCAL LADY: Tobin Saunders as the outgoing Vanessa Wagner.

BALLINA-based gender illusionist Vanessa Wagner at Vivid

Perfect time to invest in Northern Rivers property

The Northern Rivers rental market is tighter than Sydney making it the perfect time for investors to get better returns out of property than superannuation or banks deposits.

Low interest rates and tight rental market are prime time to invest